Review – A Streetcar Named Desire, Donmar Warehouse

Tuesday 28 July 2009

SCNDThe happiness of the Whingers depends on a lot of things when they visit a theatre: good sightlines, brevity, amusement and a competitively priced bar. But unlike Blanche Dubois they do not seek or expect kindness from strangers (or friends for that matter). Indeed, it is a word that rarely features in their limited vocabularies.

Brevity may also have been in somewhat short supply at the Donmar Warehouse on Monday when we dropped in to see Rob Ashford‘s production of Tennessee Williams‘s Pulitzer Prize winning classic A Streetcar Named Desire: it lumbers in at at a massive three hours. But for once the Whingers had struck lucky in the advance booking ticket lottery that the Donmar organises for its “friends” and for the first time in yonks we weren’t sitting to the side of the thrust stage but at the front, where the critics get to sit (in fact Mark Lawson or his Doppelgänger was in front of us). And boy what a difference it made!

What a welcome change not looking at the back of people’s heads or seeing actors masking each other. It was proof – if proof were needed – that the proscenium arch exists for the very good reason that theatre works best when everyone is viewing it from roughly the same direction.

Streetcar Named Desire at DonmarWith their front-on view the Whingers could fully appreciate yet another excellent design from Christopher Oram with New Orleans’ wrought iron balconies extending round the Donmar’s own circle although they did doubt whether some of the audience in the side seats could even see the thrilling, vertiginous spiral staircase. In fact there may have been some benefit to sitting there – neither Whinger is very good with heights and they were feeling a little queasy on behalf of the actors having to descend the rather wobbly staircase. But sightline-wise, goodness knows how little the poor folk at the sides could see when the curtain between the living area and the kitchen was drawn. Still, we didn’t really care as we were in the good seats for once.

Anyway, Oram’s spectacularly vertical set is complemented by some excellent atmospheric lighting by Neil Austin.

Now Rob Ashford struck the Whingers as an odd choice for director: most of his credits are musicals and Academy and Tony Awards’ production numbers. The Whingers were half-expecting something akin to Oh, Streetcar!, the brilliant musical spoof in The Simpsons. Happily (or depending on which way you look at it, sadly) this was not the case and the Whingers found themselves gripped anew by the story-telling. That said, we can’t help feeling that the musical Mister Ashford may have over-compensated somewhat as Mister Williams’ work has been pretty brutally de-camped.

This Blanche Dubois is – for the Whingers’ tastes at any rate – rather too devoid of grotesqueness. And she is so not-bonkers that when they come to take her away to the loony bin in the final scene the Whingers were rather appalled as there really didn’t seem to be anything wrong with her – certainly nothing which would seem to be out of place in either of the Whingers’ households, anyway.

But we get ahead of ourselves. For those with no cultural compass Blanche Dubois (Rachel Weisz) is the fading, well-rung Southern belle who is visiting her sister Stella (Ruth Wilson, excellent) and brutish husband Stanley Kowalski (Elliot Cowan – also excellent, but alarmingly muscular, below with Ruth Wilson) for the first time in years.

Streetcare Named Desire - Donmar - Elliot Cowan and Rachel Weisz

Cramped together in their two room apartment Blanche’s disturbed, affected plantation-owning demeanour upsets the working class Stanley who can’t wait to get rid of her, but not until he has discovered how Blanche has come to “lose” the family estate, Belle Reve, and hopefully recover something from the wreckage.

Streetcare Named Desire - Donmar - Rachel WeiszWeisz (left) is surprisingly effective as Blanche. Actually, we aren’t sure why we just wrote “surprisingly”. Why shouldn’t she be good just because she’s been in those mummy movies? She’s utterly compelling and believable but, of course, had the Whingers been at the helm she would have been a lot more bonkers.

But now, here’s a question we pondered deeply over a quick (we didn’t get out until 10.30) glass of wine afterwards: are the Blance Dubois’s getting younger these days or are the Whingers just getting older? Or both?

It’s hard to see Weisz as the faded beauty that Williams has skulking in the shadows and dimming the lights. She looks in her prime at 38 which surprisingly (to us) is the same age that Vivien Leigh and Jessica Tandy were when they played Blanche in the film and original Broadway production respectively. Didn’t people seemed older in those days or was it just because we were younger? Incredibly it appears that Blanche Dubois is actually only meant to be 28 (although the programme says the play is set in 1949, two years later than the original staging in 1947, so should we add two years?). The usually reliable Wikipedia says Blanche was born in 1919.

For the record: Glenn Close was 55 when she gave her Blanche at the National in 2002, Jessica Lange 48 at the Theatre Royal Haymarket in 1997, Claire Bloom was a mere spring chicken of 43 at the Piccadilly Theatre in 1974.

But frankly it was the Whingers’ beauty that was fading in the Donmar at Monday’s preview. Had Rob Ashford had the air-conditioning turned off to recreate the oft-referred-to steamy temperatures of New Orleans? As Stanley says, “temperature 100 on the nose”. It was certainly air-cooled in the bar and it’s a credit to the production that after an hour and three quarters sweltering in the auditorium during the first act that the Whingers dragged themselves back from the deliciously cool bar for more.

Blanche Dubois aka Snow WhitePerhaps it was the privilege of being in the good seats, but the Whingers emerged feeling that they had witnessed a most stylish production. The only fly in the ointment for Phil was Blanche’s going-away outfit – the pale yellow dress nipped in at the waist under a Della Robbia-blue jacket topped off by Weisz’s black hair in forties style reminded him of Snow White. Would the strangers delivering kindness be dwarfs? A very strange dream-filled night ensued.


Anyhoo here’s Vivien Leigh’s Academy Award winning Blanche doing the famous line.


12 Responses to “Review – A Streetcar Named Desire, Donmar Warehouse”

  1. Miriam Says:

    I’m not seeing this till September, you lucky buggers. Elliot Cowan is in my top three favourite actors, cannot WAIT to see him! Glad you had a good time!

  2. JohnnyFox Says:

    For my money, (apart from an all-Lesbian version at The Drill Hall which featured a hunky Stanley who turned on everyone in the house of all available sexes) the finest Streetcar/Blanche I’ve seen was Sheila Gish in the Alan Strachan Greenwich production which arrived at the Mermaid in 1984.

    She’d have been 41 in Greenwich and 42 at Puddle Dock, which felt ‘right’ enough for the character, and Clare Higgins was pretty ace, too, and somehow the emphasis of the piece shifted slightly towards the relationship between the two women, rather than either’s treatment by Stanley.

    and by the way, if it was so hot – when she sends Stella to the corner for “a lemon coke with lots’a chipped ice” why didn’t you say “make that three” ? 🙂

  3. I won’t be seeing this until mid-August but thanks for making me want to look forward to it with your glowing review!

  4. Apologies: In the original version of this article Andrew was in too much of a hurry to get out of the house and some of the pictures were mixed up and incorrectly captioned.

  5. Vance Says:

    What does it mean when I could feel connected with this Blanche Dubois and really GET her? (Am I crazy?) Seriously, kudos for downplaying the usual overacting crazy and really seeping into the subtleties of the piece.

    But yes, that place WAS hot wasn’t it? I thought it was just the upstairs balconies.

  6. A Clown Says:

    As one of those without a “cultural compass”, I was completely taken by surprise at the ending, and the fact that she wasn’t playing completely raving bonkers gave this moment all the more impact for me.
    I liked the heat, combined with the ironwork on the balcony, it gave a real sense of transportation to another place, which you don’t always get at the Donmar.
    And Cowan really is alarmingly muscular isn’t he, which is all the more impressive considering how much he ate during the performance (he even ate the bit of cake he dropped on the floor, now that’s dedication!)

  7. […] By webcowgirl The reviews for the Rachel Weisz / Donmar A Streetcar Named Desire are coming in, and generally speaking they are VERY enthusiastic. What are you to do, though, when the […]

  8. sam Says:

    how do u get tickets?!?!?!?!

  9. TheatreMonkey advises:

    When a production is SOLD OUT at the theatre box office, the Donmar Warehouse do hold 10 DAY SEATS for each performance, on sale daily from 10.30am, in person, from the Box Office (maximum 2 tickets per person) at £15 each. Once these are sold out, 20 STANDING PLACES in the rear circle are available at £7.50 each. Both standing and seats are normally only sold only to personal callers at the theatre box office, maximum two tickets per person.

  10. Would love to have seen Miss Weisz in the role. My only experience with the play was the last Broadway revival by the Roundabout Theatre with Natasha Richardson and the totally miscast John C Reilly. Amy Ryan’s Stella and Chris Bauer’s Mitch carried the show (sadly).

  11. […] slumming on the stage. I had been really excited about getting tickets to it (mostly thanks to the West End Whingers’ review), but this had all trickled away by the time the actual day rolled around. And, well, I had a cold […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: